MLB Video
Every offseason, there are a handful of starters who should be much better than the year before with the right adjustments. For some of these guys, it’s a matter of getting healthy. For others, a team might see something in their pitch mix it can work with. In this group, we have a Cy Young winner who fell on hard times due to injury, a veteran lefty who helped pitch Texas to a World Series title, a former All-Star with elite stuff but a risky elbow, and more. Here are five starting pitchers teams will look at as reclamation projects this offseason.
Click here to view our entire free-agent rankings, now up to 180 names.
LHP 
Age: 29 2026 bWAR: 1.1 Career bWAR: 6.5
High risk, high reward. Following an All-Star 2025, Bubic pitched reasonably well over his first nine starts with Kansas City (50.1 IP, 4.11 ERA, 3.72 FIP, 1.232 WHIP, 26 BB/51 K) although the walks were somewhat concerning. An elbow/forearm injury put him on the IL in May, and then during his rehab, he dealt with shoulder soreness, particularly concerning given his 2025 season was ended by a rotator cuff injury. It seemed like he might miss the rest of the season, but a cortisone injection in July followed by a trade to the Dodgers saw the 40th overall pick of the 2018 draft return just in time for the playoffs.
G: 14 GS: 9 IP: 55.0 SV: 0 HR: 4 BB: 26 SO: 56 ERA: 3.76 FIP: 3.54
RHP
Age: 32 2026 bWAR: 0.6 Career bWAR: 19.1
2026 was a lost season. Pitched to mediocre results over 11 starts after starting the season injured. Shut down for good in late August, posting a 4.37 ERA over 55.2 IP with 44 K/24 BB and a 1.419 WHIP. His 5.15 FIP says he got lucky. The 2020 Cy Young winner isn't anything close to that form and may never return to it. All the same, that ceiling makes him very interesting to a team with a nice pitching lab. Expect a one-year MLB prove-it deal. Very high risk, reasonably high reward.
G: 11 GS: 11 IP: 55.2 SV: 0 HR: 10 BB: 24 SO: 44 ERA: 4.37 FIP: 5.15
LHP
Age: 34 2026 bWAR: 0.1 Career bWAR: 11.2
A hero of the 2023 World Champions Texas Rangers, Montgomery made it back from Tommy John surgery and held his own in long relief, working 26 innings to a 4.15 ERA (3.87 FIP) with 6 BB/20 K and a 1.000 WHIP. Nice guy for a team in rebuild to give a rotation spot to, then trade at the deadline to a contender. Probably wouldn’t cost much with a potentially high payout.
G: 13 GS: 0 IP: 26.0 SV: 1 HR: 3 BB: 6 SO: 20 ERA: 4.15 FIP: 3.87
RHP
Age: 31 2026 bWAR: -0.1 Career bWAR: 14.2
Flaherty dealt with an ankle/foot injury after slipping on the mound in June, and then a right forearm injury that kept him out from late July until the final day of the season. Results were mediocre when he was healthy; over 88.1 innings he posted a 4.48 ERA (4.05 FIP), and a 1.392 WHIP with 42 BB/103 K. His K/9 was very nice at 10.5, equal to his 2025 season although, concerningly, his BB/9 went up from 3.3 to 4.3. Pedigree and relative youth should be enough to get him another rotation opportunity.
G: 20 GS: 19 IP: 88.1 SV: 0 HR: 11 BB: 42 SO: 103 ERA: 4.48 FIP: 4.05
RHP
Age: 32 2026 bWAR: -0.2 Career bWAR: 14.0
After a surprisingly effective 2025 for the Red Sox, Giolito signed late in the offseason with the Padres and never really got it going. He made five starts and worked 29.2 ineffective innings before going on the IL with elbow discomfort in late June and never returned. A lost season, as is often the case when a player waits too long to sign. Not getting any younger.
G: 7 GS: 5 IP: 29.2 SV: 0 HR: 4 BB: 23 SO: 18 ERA: 5.16 FIP: 6.07













Recommended Comments
There are no comments to display.
If you have an account on one of the following sites, you have a DiamondCentric account.
Twins Daily, Brewer Fanatic, North Side Baseball, Talk Sox, Jays Centre, Padres Mission, Royals Keep, Grand Central Mets, Fish On First.
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now