Jump to content
DiamondCentric
  • MLB News & Analysis

    Five Underrated Free Agent Starting Pitchers

    If you're looking for a starter with upside while keeping to a budget, here are five good options.

    Ed Hand

    MLB Video

    Starting pitching is expensive. It doesn’t take much for a team to find itself paying a whole lot of money for what turns out to be a fairly mediocre pitcher who breaks down halfway through the season. There are usually a few bargains to be found if you’re willing to look into the cause of some ugly back-of-the-baseball-card numbers or take a risk on the right pitcher with a known history of injuries. None of these guys are aces, but they all have something going for them that makes it plausible there’s more potential than the consensus would lead one to believe.

    Click here to read our entire list of over 200 free agents.

    LHP Braves Age: 36 2026 bWAR: 2.9 Career bWAR: 18.5
    Came back from the depths of baseball oblivion to post an excellent year for a pitching-needy Atlanta Braves. His 3.04 ERA over 142 innings probably isn't sustainable (his 4.32 FIP is a more realistic expectation), but there are far worse options for the back of a rotation than a crafty veteran lefty with a history of success.
    G: 30 GS: 26 IP: 142.0 SV: 0 HR: 14 BB: 62 SO: 102 ERA: 3.04 FIP: 4.32
    RHP Diamondbacks Age: 29 2026 bWAR: 2.2 Career bWAR: 9.1
    The Alberta native stayed (mostly) healthy and finished 2026 with the best season of his career since his impressive rookie year in 2019: 3.41 ERA/3.19 FIP, 114 K/29 BB, 1.086 WHIP over 116 IP (21 starts). His 2.3 BB/9 was also the best since his rookie year, as was his 0.8 HR/9. In short, when he doesn't walk many batters and limits hard contact to the point where he gives up less than a home run per nine, Soroka is a very solid middle-of-the-rotation starter. Health remains a legitimate concern.
    G: 22 GS: 21 IP: 116.0 SV: 0 HR: 10 BB: 29 SO: 114 ERA: 3.41 FIP: 3.19
    RHP GiantsBraves Age: 32 2026 bWAR: 1.6 Career bWAR: 12.8
    Improved substantially following a deadline trade to the Braves; the veteran righty posted a 1.99 ERA over 54.1 IP for the playoff push with 48 K/9 BB. For the full season, his 3.99 ERA actually matched his 3.99 FIP, which is fun and unusual. Perhaps most importantly, he stayed mostly healthy, working 149 IP over 27 starts, both the second highest of Mahle's career. Good work proving his 2025 half-season wasn't a total fluke. The question now is how many years will a team offer to see if he can sustain it?
    G: 27 GS: 27 IP: 149.0 SV: 0 HR: 20 BB: 46 SO: 137 ERA: 3.99 FIP: 3.99
    LHP MetsCubs Age: 31 2026 bWAR: -0.1 Career bWAR: 6.8
    A tale of two halves. Absolutely awful with the Mets (who wasn’t?) with an unsightly 6.09 ERA over 68 IP to go with 63 K/30 BB and a 1.647 WHIP. The one saving grace of this is that his 3.85 FIP supported supremely bad luck. A trade to the Cubs flipped things somewhat. Over 80.1 innings following said trade, the 2017 first-round pick posted a much better 3.70 ERA with 74 K/35 BB and a 1.369 WHIP. Funny enough, his FIP was 4.19, indicating that his luck significantly improved following the trade. Or maybe the Cubs defense was just a lot better. Either way, Peterson is very much still a perfectly capable back-of-the-rotation starter.
    G: 32 GS: 23 IP: 148.1 SV: 1 HR: 15 BB: 65 SO: 137 ERA: 4.79 FIP: 3.96
    RHP Rangers Age: 32 2026 bWAR: 2.0 Career bWAR: 9.7
    It seemed like Quantrill was on his way out after increasingly poor seasons in 2023, 2024, and 2025. Caught on with Texas and was able to turn the opportunity into his best season since 2022. Over 110 IP (15 starts, 32 total appearances), the Ontario native posted a 2.86 ERA with a 1.036 WHIP and 81 K/25 BB. Still a sinkerball pitcher, he threw his four-seamer more and his cutter, curveball, and slider less in 2026. There was absolutely some luck involved, as will always be the case with guys who pitch to contact, but without question, Quantrill has earned another opportunity to start in 2027.
    G: 32 GS: 15 IP: 110.0 SV: 0 HR: 13 BB: 25 SO: 81 ERA: 2.86 FIP: 4.01

    Follow DiamondCentric For Major League Baseball News & Analysis

    Like what you've read here? Check out our team-specific sites and expand your fandom!

    Recent MLB Articles

    Recent MLB Videos


    User Feedback

    Recommended Comments

    There are no comments to display.



    If you have an account on one of the following sites, you have a DiamondCentric account.

    Twins Daily, Brewer Fanatic, North Side Baseball, Talk Sox, Jays Centre, Padres Mission, Royals Keep, Grand Central Mets, Fish On First.

    Create an account or sign in to comment

    You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

    Create an account

    Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

    Register a new account

    Sign in

    Already have an account? Sign in here.

    Sign In Now

×
×
  • Create New...